Artificial intelligence (AI) in education is robbing students of the crucial drafting stage in writing college essays, hindering their development of critical thinking and growth.
Despite the push for AI proficiency, students should be encouraged to cultivate their own original thoughts and express them truthfully and coherently, particularly in tasks like writing college essays.
The use of AI in education presents conflicting messages to students, posing a risk to their development of critical thinking skills, especially in preparation for important life events like future job opportunities and elections.
Summarized
The text discusses the impact of artificial intelligence (AI) on high school students, particularly in the context of college essay writing. The writer, a teacher with over 20 years of experience, expresses concerns about AI robbing students of the critical thinking and self-expression that comes with the drafting process of writing. The text highlights how AI could devalue original thoughts and critical thinking skills, and how its use in education may lead to cheating. The writer emphasizes the importance of students developing their own ideas and voices, especially in the context of college essays and future opportunities. The overall message emphasizes the need for students to think critically and express their thoughts truthfully, and the potential negative consequences of outsourcing imagination and creativity to AI.
Recognizing Words and Phrases
"Artificial intelligence (AI) in education" (Noun Phrase)
"Robbing students of the crucial drafting stage" (Verb Phrase)
"Critical thinking and growth" (Noun Phrase)
"Original thoughts and express them truthfully and coherently" (Phrase)
"Conflicting messages" (Noun Phrase)
"Important life events like future job opportunities and elections" (Noun Phrase)
Clarifying Meanings
"Artificial intelligence (AI) in education":
Definition: The application and integration of AI technologies within educational systems and processes.
Contextual Use: Refers to the influence and role of AI tools in teaching and learning environments.
"Robbing students of the crucial drafting stage":
Definition: Depriving students of the essential process of creating initial versions of their work, which is vital for developing ideas and refining their writing.
Contextual Use: Suggests that reliance on AI diminishes a critical part of the learning and writing experience.
"Critical thinking and growth":
Definition: The development of the ability to analyze and evaluate information objectively and make reasoned judgments, and the overall personal and intellectual development.
Contextual Use: Emphasizes skills and personal development that are essential in education.
"Original thoughts and express them truthfully and coherently":
Definition: The ability to generate unique ideas and present them in an honest and logical manner.
Contextual Use: Stresses the importance of personal creativity and clear communication in writing.
"Conflicting messages":
Definition: Mixed or contradictory information and expectations.
Contextual Use: Highlights the inconsistency in the educational approach when AI tools are used.
"Important life events like future job opportunities and elections":
Definition: Significant occurrences that can have a major impact on a person’s career and civic life.
Contextual Use: Indicates the long-term implications of critical thinking skills beyond education.
Suggesting Synonyms and Noting Distinctions
"Artificial intelligence (AI) in education":
Synonyms: "AI-enhanced learning," "Educational AI systems," "Intelligent educational technologies."
Distinctions: "AI-enhanced learning" focuses on the enhancement role, "Educational AI systems" highlights the tools themselves, "Intelligent educational technologies" emphasizes the smart nature of the tech.
"Robbing students of the crucial drafting stage":
Synonyms: "Depriving students of essential revision stages," "Eliminating the key drafting process," "Taking away students' initial writing phase."
Distinctions: "Depriving" implies a severe loss, "Eliminating" suggests complete removal, "Taking away" is more general.
"Critical thinking and growth":
Synonyms: "Analytical reasoning and development," "Reflective thinking and personal growth," "Evaluative thinking and intellectual advancement."
Distinctions: "Analytical reasoning" focuses on analysis, "Reflective thinking" involves introspection, "Evaluative thinking" emphasizes judgment.
"Original thoughts and express them truthfully and coherently":
Synonyms: "Unique ideas and articulate them honestly and logically," "Innovative thinking and present it clearly and sincerely," "Creative concepts and convey them accurately and cohesively."
Distinctions: "Unique ideas" emphasize originality, "Innovative thinking" suggests creativity, "Creative concepts" highlights inventiveness.
"Conflicting messages":
Synonyms: "Contradictory signals," "Mixed signals," "Inconsistent communication."
Distinctions: "Contradictory signals" implies direct opposition, "Mixed signals" can be more informal, "Inconsistent communication" is broader.
"Important life events like future job opportunities and elections":
Synonyms: "Significant milestones such as career opportunities and voting events," "Major life occurrences including employment prospects and elections," "Critical life junctions like jobs and civic responsibilities."
Distinctions: "Significant milestones" suggests achievements, "Major life occurrences" is more broad, "Critical life junctions" emphasizes decision points.